Johnny Depp's return in Paramount's "Ebenezer" sparks backlash as one critic argues Hollywood is celebrating him too soon. The Critic Argues Johnny Depp’s Hollywood Comeback Isn’t Earned first appeared on The Blast

Johnny Depp is stepping back into the Hollywood spotlight as Ebenezer Scrooge in Paramount’s dark new take on A Christmas Carol.

One critic has pushed back against celebrations surrounding Depp’s return, arguing that the film’s marketing glosses over the controversies that derailed his career. Much of the backlash stems from his bitter legal battle with ex-wife Amber Heard, which damaged his reputation and cost him several major roles.

Johnny Depp Teases Hollywood Return With First ‘Ebenezer’ Trailer

Johnny Depp is set to return to major Hollywood studio filmmaking in Paramount’s dark reimagining of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol. The actor unveiled the first trailer for Ebenezer after making a surprise appearance in full costume as Ebenezer Scrooge at San Diego Comic-Con, staying in character as the famously bitter miser throughout.

Directed by horror filmmaker Ti West, the movie puts a darker spin on the classic holiday tale, with Scrooge haunted by terrifying versions of the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Yet to Come. The film also boasts a star-studded cast that includes Ian McKellen, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Daisy Ridley, and Sam Claflin.

Ebenezer is scheduled to hit theaters on November 13 and is being positioned as Depp’s first major studio release in years. The trailer even features the pointed line, “I’m back,” a moment many fans have interpreted as a nod to both Scrooge’s story and the actor’s Hollywood comeback.

Guardian Critic Questions Johnny Depp’s Hollywood Return

Not everyone is celebrating Depp’s return to Hollywood. In a sharply critical review for The Guardian, columnist Stuart Heritage argued that the actor’s new role as Ebenezer Scrooge asks audiences to overlook the controversies that have defined his recent years.

Heritage pointed to the trailer’s emphasis on Depp’s comeback, including the tagline calling him the “master of misfits” and the line, “I’m back.” He argued that, rather than simply promoting a new film, the marketing deliberately positions Ebenezer as Depp’s return to mainstream Hollywood.

The columnist also questioned whether enough time has passed since Depp’s court cases and abuse allegations for such a comeback to feel comfortable. While acknowledging that the film’s horror elements under director Ti West could suit the actor’s public image, Heritage suggested a darker role may be easier for audiences to embrace than a conventional redemption story. Even so, he conceded that the movie’s box office performance in November will ultimately determine whether the comeback succeeds.

Amber Heard Case Reshaped Johnny Depp’s Career

Depp’s public downfall was largely driven by his bitter legal battles with ex-wife Amber Heard. She accused him of domestic abuse, allegations he repeatedly denied. In 2020, Depp lost his UK libel case against The Sun, with the judge finding the newspaper’s description of him as a “wife beater” was “substantially true,” according to Reuters.

Two years later, a Virginia jury largely sided with Depp in the former couple’s dueling defamation claims. Heard was ordered to pay him damages, while Depp was also found liable over one statement made by his attorney.

His controversies extend beyond the marriage. City of Lies crew member Gregg Brooks accused Depp of punching him on set, though the actor denied the allegation and the lawsuit was later settled. His lavish spending and legal disputes with former financial managers have also generated years of damaging headlines.

Depp’s Legal Problems Cost Him Roles

At the height of his legal battles, Depp’s standing in Hollywood suffered a significant hit as major studios began moving away from him. After the UK libel case in 2020, Warner Bros. asked him to step down from the “Fantastic Beasts” franchise, replacing him as dark wizard Gellert Grindelwald.

His future as Captain Jack Sparrow also became uncertain. During the 2022 Virginia defamation trial, Depp’s longtime agent testified that Disney had moved in “a different direction” with the “Pirates of the Caribbean” franchise following the allegations against the actor, although the company has never publicly confirmed that was the reason.

Speaking to The Telegraph last year, Depp said he felt “shunned, dumped, booted, deep-sixed, canceled” by the industry after losing the role. While he continued making films overseas, his upcoming turn as Scrooge in “Ebenezer” is widely being viewed as one of his most serious attempts yet to reestablish himself in mainstream Hollywood.

Johnny Depp Says Hollywood Tried To ‘Retire’ Him

After years spent largely working outside the studio system, Depp spoke candidly about how his departure from the Fantastic Beasts franchise affected him.

In his interview with The Telegraph, he claimed Warner Bros.’ request that he resign felt less like a casting change and more like an attempt to force him into retirement. Rather than stepping away, Depp said the experience only strengthened his resolve to keep acting, insisting he never considered giving up.

With his return in Lionsgate’s Day Drinker opposite Penélope Cruz, followed by his starring role in Ebenezer, Depp appears to be making a gradual but steady return to major Hollywood productions after spending several years on the industry’s sidelines.

The Critic Argues Johnny Depp’s Hollywood Comeback Isn’t Earned first appeared on The Blast