Jennie Garth Reveals Why Her Friendship With Tiffani Thiessen Ended

Jennie Garth opens up about her fallout with Tiffani Thiessen, revealing how their close bond quietly came to an end The Jennie Garth Reveals Why Her Friendship With Tiffani Thiessen Ended first appeared on The Blast

Time has a way of reshaping even the closest bonds, and for Jennie Garth, one of her most cherished friendships ultimately faded into something distant.

In her latest reflections, the actress opens up about her complicated relationship with former co-star Tiffani Thiessen, revealing how a once-tight connection evolved into something that no longer exists today.

Jennie Garth Opens Up About Friendship That Didn’t Last

For Jennie Garth, revisiting her past has meant confronting some difficult truths.

In her newly-released memoir, she doesn’t shy away from addressing her fractured relationship with Tiffani Thiessen.

“Tiffani and I didn’t have such a happy ending with our friendship,” Garth writes per Page Six in “I Choose Me.”

She adds, “We’re no longer close.”

Those simple yet direct statements set the tone for a story that stretches back decades, filled with both meaningful connection and eventual distance.

Jennie Garth And Tiffani Thiessen’s Friendship Began With Tension

Their relationship began in 1994, when Thiessen joined “Beverly Hills, 90210” during its fifth season.

From the start, Garth admits that her reaction wasn’t entirely welcoming.

“Her character brought tension, complexity, and a fresh energy to the ensemble,” Garth writes, while also acknowledging that she initially “felt threatened and competitive” with the “Saved by the Bell” alum, “just as I had with many beautiful co-stars before.”

Rather than letting that tension linger, Garth recognized the pattern in her behavior and chose to address it.

She apologized to Thiessen, and that moment of honesty laid the foundation for a strong bond.

“That’s how we became best friends during her years on ‘90210.’”

Their connection grew quickly, evolving into a genuine friendship that extended far beyond the set.

Garth Helped Shape A Major Moment In Thiessen’s Life

As their friendship deepened, Jenni Garth became an important figure in Tiffani Thiessen’s personal life as well.

One of the most memorable moments came when she introduced Thiessen to actor Brady Smith.

“He was tall and handsome and from Texas,” Garth writes, explaining why she believed the match would work. “And I just had the feeling they would hit it off. I called her right away and told her to come down to the set to meet this cute guy … Cut to: They’ve been married for years with a gorgeous family.”

The anecdote highlights just how close the two once were, with Garth playing a role in shaping a life-changing relationship for her friend.

Their bond was strong enough that Thiessen even stood beside Garth as a bridesmaid at her wedding to Peter Facinelli in 2001.

Garth Reflects On Why The Connection Faded

Despite the closeness they once shared, Jennie Garth admits that the friendship eventually lost its spark.

While she has never publicly detailed a specific cause, she acknowledges that something shifted over time.

“The connection we once shared wasn’t there,” Garth writes.

Her perspective now leans toward acceptance rather than blame. She adds, “I’ve come to see that some friendships are meant for a reason or a season, and ours was a meaningful one, while it lasted.”

Thiessen, for her part, offered her own insight during a 2012 appearance on “The Howard Stern Show,” where she confirmed the distance between them.

She shared that they “had a falling out and we grew apart,” before adding, “I was the one who was hurt, let’s just say that.”

Together, their reflections paint a picture of a friendship that ended not with a single dramatic moment, but with a gradual emotional shift.

Personal Struggles Shaped Jennie Garth’s Journey Forward

While her friendship with Thiessen was evolving, Garth was also navigating deeply personal challenges in her own life. Her marriage to Peter Facinelli came to a painful end, marking another turning point.

Speaking on Dax Shepard’s “Armchair Expert” podcast, Garth recalled a moment in therapy that changed everything.

She revealed that a couple’s counselor asked her why she was with someone who didn’t love her. “That’s where everything hit the fan,” she said.

“It was echoing,” she added, “I’ll never forget it. That just gutted me, and I was like, ‘Yeah, no sh-t. Give up, it’s time.’”

She also remembered the moment Facinelli told her their marriage was over, recalling his words: “Jen, someday you’ll thank me for this.” The comment, she admitted, “infuriated me, that p-ssed me off.”

The emotional toll of the divorce was significant. Garth later revealed to PEOPLE that she struggled in its aftermath.

“I noticed my light really dimming,” she said. “I wasn’t putting off good vibes. I could see it in the mirror. I could look at the negative impact that that kind of grief and anger was having on me.”

Through it all, Garth has emerged with a clearer sense of self and a willingness to reflect on both the highs and lows of her past.

Whether it’s lost friendships or personal heartbreak, her story is one of growth, resilience, and learning to let go of what no longer fits.

The Jennie Garth Reveals Why Her Friendship With Tiffani Thiessen Ended first appeared on The Blast